The article “Insurable Interest as the Basis for Distinguishing Insurance from Gambling”, published in the seventh issue of Juridica in 2018, is authored by insurance law experts Olavi-Jüri Luik and Kärt Saar. It is a thorough legal analysis that explains the concept of insurable interest and its critical role in differentiating an insurance contract from a gambling arrangement. The article is especially relevant for insurers, brokers, attorneys, and legislators involved in shaping the legal framework of the insurance market.
The concept of insurable interest essentially means that only a person who has a personal, financially measurable interest in the occurrence (or non-occurrence) of an insured event may enter into an insurance contract. This interest may stem from a proprietary connection to the insured object (e.g., ownership, loan, lease, liability) or from a personal relationship (e.g., family ties in life insurance).
The aim of this principle is to prevent insurance from becoming a form of gambling, where a person places a bet on the occurrence of an event without having any incentive to avoid it. Without insurable interest, insurance could become a lottery, where the insured has a financial motive to cause the insured event – for instance, setting fire to a stranger’s car to claim insurance benefits.
The principle of insurable interest emerged in 18th-century England as a response to the widespread practice of insuring ships or lives without any personal connection. These types of contracts created both ethical and practical problems. To prevent such abuse, legislation like the Marine Insurance Act 1746 was enacted to require the existence of an insurable interest.
Modern insurance law has developed a more nuanced view of insurable interest. In addition to direct property interests, policies may also be taken out on close relations if their death or property loss would result in financial harm or dependency-related consequences. In Islamic law, traditional insurance is still contested due to its perceived gambling elements.
In Estonia, the principle of insurable interest is codified in § 478 of the Law of Obligations Act (VÕS). However, this provision is limited in scope and primarily applies to non-life (indemnity) insurance. According to the article’s authors, this regulation should equally apply to all types of insurance, including sum insurance (e.g., life or accident insurance).
The concept is also referenced in the Motor Insurance Act and the Insurance Activities Act, although with differing meanings. Whereas VÕS treats insurable interest as a legal precondition for contract validity, the Insurance Activities Act interprets it more broadly as the client’s insurance need or preference.
The article highlights several real-world examples from the Estonian market that raise questions about the existence of insurable interest:
In these cases, it is unclear whether the policyholder has a genuine insurable interest, or whether the arrangements constitute hidden intermediation or even resemble a lottery. According to the authors, such structures are legally acceptable, provided the insured person later consents to the contract.
The article highlights a major issue: Estonian law does not clearly define the consequences of lacking insurable interest. Does it render the contract void? Does it release the insurer from obligations? Or does it simply terminate the agreement? There is also no clear mechanism for determining whether insurable interest exists at the time of contracting.
In practice, this ambiguity leaves insurers with broad discretion, and the mere existence of the principle does not guarantee its consistent enforcement.
Insurable interest is a cornerstone of insurance law. It ensures that an insurance policy is a risk management tool, not a wager. Although this principle exists in Estonian law, it is not defined clearly or applied uniformly. The authors call on legislators to more precisely determine when insurable interest is required and what the legal consequences of its absence should be.
Therefore, to avoid scenarios where insurance resembles gambling, the law must clearly establish who must have insurable interest and when. An experienced insurance law attorney can help identify whether an insurance contract is valid and compliant in practice.
If you want to know more about insurable interest or the validity of insurance contracts, contact our insurance law attorney – you’ll receive practical answers to even the most complex questions.
Mes esame WIDEN – verslo teisės advokatų kontora, teikianti visą teisinių paslaugų spektrą Baltijos šalyse bei kurianti geriausią galimą patirtį savo klientams. Daugiausia dėmesio būtent jiems ir skiriame – užtikriname, jog mūsų konsultacijos atlieptų visus klientų verslo poreikius.
Klientai