In September 2017, the legal journal Juridica published a comprehensive article titled “Policyholder’s Post-Claim Obligations in Property Insurance”. The article was authored by a leading expert in insurance law, Olavi-Jüri Luik, an experienced insurance law attorney. The article focuses on the policyholder’s rights and obligations following the occurrence of an insured event—primarily in the context of property insurance (also known as insurance of things).
The insurer is not automatically obligated to pay compensation in every insured event. Estonian law—specifically LOA § 452 and § 488—provides several grounds on which an insurer may refuse or reduce indemnity. One of the key factors is the policyholder’s conduct after the insured event.
The first and most immediate obligation following an insured event is to prevent or minimize damage. The policyholder is expected to act as if no insurance contract existed—that is, reasonably and proactively.
For example, if rainwater is pouring into the house through a storm-damaged roof, the homeowner must cover or repair the roof as soon as possible to avoid further damage. If the policyholder fails to act and the damage worsens, the insurer may lawfully refuse to compensate for the additional loss.
The law expects that such mitigation efforts are objectively reasonable and feasible. Even if the action fails but was justified, it is not considered a breach of duty. However, the policyholder is not required to risk their health or life in order to fulfill this obligation.
The second critical obligation is to promptly notify the insurer about the insured event. Whether it’s a burglary, fire, or flood, the policyholder must inform the insurer without delay. Late notification can hinder the assessment of the loss or make it harder to identify the responsible party.
If the policyholder intentionally fails to notify the insurer and this leads to loss for the insurer, the insurer may be released from the duty to indemnify.
Example from case law: A policyholder notified the insurer about a theft but omitted to mention some of the stolen items. The court ruled this to be a significant breach of duty and upheld the insurer’s decision to deny part of the indemnity.
The third obligation is the duty to cooperate with the insurer in determining the circumstances and extent of the loss. This means the policyholder must provide necessary information, allow the insurer to investigate the event, submit relevant documents, and not obstruct inspection of the damaged property.
The duty of cooperation also applies when a criminal investigation has been initiated in connection with the insured event—such as theft or arson. In such cases, it is often necessary to involve public authorities (e.g., police, rescue service), enabling the insurer to later pursue subrogation against the liable party.
Particular attention must be paid to the provision of false information. If the policyholder deliberately misrepresents the extent or circumstances of the damage, the insurer may deny indemnity in full or in part. This applies especially when such misrepresentation makes it harder to assess the event or quantify the loss.
Even if the false information doesn’t affect the entire claim, it may still result in a partial refusal of payment. Misleading the insurer not only risks the indemnity but may also raise suspicions of insurance fraud.
The article makes it clear that a policyholder has three main obligations after an insured event:
Meeting these obligations helps avoid situations where the insurer refuses payment. It also builds mutual trust—because an insurance contract is not just a legal document, but also a relationship based on trust.
The article’s author, Olavi-Jüri Luik, is a seasoned insurance law attorney, whose expertise benefits both insurers and policyholders in navigating complex legal environments. His analysis offers valuable insights for anyone with a property insurance policy or those seeking to understand how to act when unexpected damage occurs.
Мы – WIDEN, балтийская юридическая фирма, которая предлагает своим клиентам полный спектр услуг и гордится тем, что предоставляемые ей юридические консультации ориентированы на клиентский опыт.
Clients