На главную страницу > Новости и события > Will Insurance Replace Tort? An Insurance Law Attorney’s Analysis on AI and Autonomous Vehicles

Will Insurance Replace Tort? An Insurance Law Attorney’s Analysis on AI and Autonomous Vehicles
1 января, 2019 о наших новостях

In the 7/2024 issue of Juridica, insurance law attorney Olavi-Jüri Luik and Rauno Kinkar published an article titled “Artificial Intelligence and Extra-Contractual Liability: Will the Insurance System Replace Tort Law in the Future?” The article examines the civil liability of autonomous land vehicles and addresses the central question: how should future damages be compensated when driving decisions are no longer made by humans, but by artificial intelligence? 

The study also builds on Luik’s AI law thesis prepared at the University of Lisbon and takes a deep dive into how insurance law can adapt to a technological shift where SAE level 4 and 5 vehicles operate entirely without human drivers. 

Technology Moving Ahead, the Law Falling Behind? 

Autonomous vehicle testing and early adoption show that technology is progressing faster than legal frameworks. Up to SAE level 3, the driver remains responsible, but with levels 4 and 5, a human may not be present at all. This raises a fundamental question: who bears liability when the decision is made by an algorithm or a sensor instead of a person? 

Current tort law assumes that harm results from human fault. But when no human error is involved, and the potential source is software, data systems, or the vehicle’s design, the very foundation of liability becomes blurred. 

Insurance as an Alternative to Tort? 

Luik and Kinkar explore whether tort law might partly retreat in the context of autonomous vehicles and whether a new insurance-based approach could take its place. The key idea: damages would be covered automatically, regardless of fault. This would reduce disputes and speed up compensation. 

The article compares four possible models: 

  1. Mandatory Cyber Insurance. This would cover damages caused by hacking or cybersecurity failures. However, it would not cover other risks (such as software bugs or sensor malfunctions), making the system fragmented and confusing for consumers. 
  1. Product Liability Insurance. Responsibility would shift to the manufacturer or software developer. The challenge here is the “development risk” principle – producers may avoid liability if the harm was scientifically unforeseeable at the time of production. 
  1. Amending the EU Motor Insurance Directive (MID). The authors see this as the most realistic option. The existing EU motor insurance framework could be expanded to explicitly cover autonomous vehicles within the same system as conventional ones. 
  1. No-Fault Insurance. Similar to vaccine compensation schemes, damages would be paid regardless of fault. While legally simpler, this model could increase moral hazard, create parallel systems, and add complexity for consumers. 

The Practical View of an Insurance Law Attorney 

From a practical standpoint, an insurance law attorney emphasizes that splitting coverage into separate policies—such as requiring vehicle owners to hold motor insurance, cyber insurance, and product liability insurance simultaneously—would create legal and consumer confusion. Instead, the authors recommend strengthening the existing EU motor insurance system (MID) so that both autonomous and non-autonomous vehicles fall under one coherent framework. 

This approach would simplify consumer obligations, avoid overlapping systems, and ensure consistency in claims handling. 

Will Insurance Truly Replace Tort? 

The article concludes that insurance may indeed partly replace tort law in the context of autonomous vehicles, but not completely. Liability as a legal concept will not disappear—it will simply evolve and require redefinition. 

The role of an insurance law attorney becomes crucial here: to participate in legislative debates, advise businesses, and help design future-proof insurance solutions that can keep pace with rapid technological change. 

Заключение 

The rise of autonomous vehicles will transform the very foundations of liability law. Luik and Kinkar recommend against creating a new, parallel no-fault insurance system. Instead, they argue for reforming the existing EU motor insurance framework so that autonomous vehicles are integrated into the same compensation system as conventional cars. 

This unified approach would avoid consumer confusion, minimize legal fragmentation, and provide a future-ready structure for handling damages in an AI-driven world. 

Основные члены команды

Olavi Juri Luikv
Олави-Юри Луйк
Партнёр
Rauno Kinkarv
Рауно Кинкар
Партнёр

другие

НОВОСТИ И СОБЫТИЯ Подробнее

New comparative guideline for Baltic Corporate, Tax and Employment legislation for entrepreneurs

Налоговое право / Корпоративное право, слияния и поглощения
Typewriter with WIDEN-branded paper in an office
Newly released Corporate and Tax Data Sheet for the Baltic Countries, a comprehe...
Читать подробнее

Номинация Латвийской Республики: Янис Эшенвалдс включён в состав Коллегии примирителей ICSID

Страхование / Технология
Jānis Ešenvalds with ICSID Panel of Conciliators announcement
The International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), part of ...
Читать подробнее

Следите за развитиями событий в правовой сфере в странах Балтии. Оставайтесь в курсе событий с помощью нашей новостной рассылки.

О юридической фирме WIDEN

Подробнее

Мы – WIDEN, балтийская юридическая фирма, которая предлагает своим клиентам полный спектр услуг и гордится тем, что предоставляемые ей юридические консультации ориентированы на клиентский опыт.

Clients

decathlon
Ryanair
delfi
norstat
rietumu_banka
hanza
foxway